Old Town Auto Service

Business Details

50+ Years

experience

Your Trusted Auto Repair Experts in Eureka, CA

Founded in 1975, Old Town Auto Service has been a trusted name in automotive repair for nearly five decades. As a family-owned business, we prioritize honesty, integrity, and personalized service, ensuring every customer receives expert care for their vehicle. Our team of ASE-certified technicians combines decades of experience with cutting-edge technology to deliver reliable solutions for brake repairs, transmission services, and comprehensive maintenance. With a 48-month/48,000-mile nationwide warranty, we stand behind our work to provide peace of mind for every client. Located in Eureka, California, we serve Humboldt County and surrounding areas, offering amenities like 24-hour key drop and shuttle service to enhance convenience.

Our commitment to excellence has earned us AAA approval and the trust of generations of drivers. We continuously invest in training and equipment to stay at the forefront of automotive advancements while maintaining the values that built our reputation. Customer satisfaction remains our top priority, whether addressing routine maintenance or complex diagnostics. By blending technical expertise with a client-focused approach, we ensure every visit meets the highest standards of quality and reliability.

Services

Brake Repairs Transmission Repairs Oil Changes Tune-Ups Check Engine Light Tire Replacements Alignment General Maintenance Fuel Injection Cleaning Electrical Diagnostics

Details

Year established: 1975

Highlights and features

Family-owned since 1975 with decades of local automotive expertise
ASE-certified technicians trained in the latest automotive technologies
48-month/48,000-mile nationwide warranty on all repairs
24-hour key drop for after-hours service convenience
Complimentary shuttle service for customer mobility needs

Associations and certifications

What people say

Knowledgeable, honest, reliable mechanics Diagnosed problems quickly Explained everything in detail Hassle-free experience Peace of mind

Website

Update Listing

Services

Brake Repairs

Our brake repair service addresses worn pads, damaged rotors, and hydraulic system issues using manufacturer-grade parts. Technicians perform comprehensive diagnostics to ensure optimal stopping power and safety. Customers benefit from extended brake life and improved vehicle performance through our precision repairs.

Transmission Repairs

We specialize in both automatic and manual transmission repairs, including fluid changes, clutch replacements, and solenoid fixes. Advanced diagnostic tools identify issues early, preventing costly breakdowns. Our work ensures smoother gear shifts and prolonged transmission longevity for passenger vehicles and light trucks.

Oil Changes

Regular oil changes use high-quality synthetic blends to maintain engine efficiency. Technicians inspect fluid levels, replace oil filters, and check for leaks during each service. This routine maintenance extends engine life and maintains manufacturer warranty requirements for optimal vehicle performance.

Check Engine Light

Our computer diagnostics identify engine management system faults triggering check engine lights. Technicians use specialized scanners to read error codes and perform targeted repairs. This service prevents minor issues from becoming major mechanical failures while improving fuel efficiency and emissions compliance.

Tune-Ups

Modern tune-ups include spark plug replacement, fuel system cleaning, and ignition component inspections. Technicians optimize engine timing and idle speed for improved acceleration and fuel economy. Regular tune-ups restore vehicle performance to factory specifications while reducing long-term maintenance costs.

People

Wally Cunningham

Founder

Founded Old Town Auto Service in 1975 after working as an auto mechanic. Built the business into a trusted local repair shop before passing leadership to his son Steve.

Steve Cunningham

Owner

Joined the family business in the 1980s, expanding operations from a 2-bay to 12-bay facility. Now co-owns the shop with his wife Lacee, overseeing daily operations and technician training.

Lacee Cunningham

Co-Owner

Co-owns the business with Steve, managing customer service teams and ensuring operational excellence. Focuses on maintaining family values while implementing modern service standards for continued business growth.

Questions

What auto repair services do you offer?

We provide brake repairs, transmission services, oil changes, check engine diagnostics, tune-ups, tire replacements, alignment, and general maintenance for all vehicle types.

Do you offer warranties on repairs?

Yes, we provide a 48-month/48,000-mile nationwide warranty covering parts and labor for most repairs performed at our facility.

What are your business hours?

We operate Monday through Friday from 7:30 AM to 5:00 PM. Emergency key drop service is available after hours for added convenience.

Which areas do you service?

We serve Eureka, Arcata, McKinleyville, Kneeland, Garberville, Fortuna, Ferndale, Cutten, and surrounding Humboldt County communities.

Are your technicians certified?

All technicians hold ASE certifications across multiple automotive specialties, ensuring qualified expertise for every repair and maintenance task we perform.

What customer amenities do you provide?

We offer complimentary coffee, shuttle service, 24-hour key drop, and a comfortable waiting area with Wi-Fi during regular business hours.

Reviews (6)

Write a Review

MAc Man

Jun 17, 2022 Report

I have always been very impressed by the politeness and courtesy of the staff. Might not be the cheapest option, but I enjoy the staff and trust the work im having done. Services: Wheel alignment, Auto maintenance, Brakes, Steering & suspension repair, Auto engine tuning, Transmission repair

Steve Allen

Apr 09, 2022 Report

They took the time to check a quote from another company, and their great customer service made me feel a lot more at ease with the money I was spending, despite the fact that I wasn't yet a paying customer. Thank you for your time! Highly recommend this auto shop.

Larry Schall

Feb 26, 2022 Report

Hello. Yes. After further inspections, Old Town Services found and corrected everything. To let my vehicle back on the road safely until the next service. I always feel that their compassion for automotive troubles are Remedied by there history in this field. Thank you Old Town Auto. Larry & Shari Schall Services: Brakes, Auto interior vacuuming, Steering & suspension repair, Auto engine tuning, General repairs & maintenance, Oil change, Auto engine diagnostic

Halle Ludwig

Jan 08, 2022 Report

Super friendly and finished my car two days earlier than expected which is exactly what we needed since we were getting ready to move cross country. The cost was significantly cheaper than expected and they explained everything they were doing in detail. My 2012 Mazda is running like new now.

Jorey M.

Dec 27, 2021 Report

Old Town Auto Service has serviced our vehicles for the past 10 years. They are professional, kind, and always deliver within the estimated time. We are satisfied with the quality of their repairs and service. When I took in a vehicle that was in really bad shape, they gave me an estimate but also suggested that it may not be worth the cost of repairing due to several factors. I was happy that I could trust them to give me honest feedback and service and not try to force an expensive repair. They care about us as a long-term customer and show that with the follow-up calls to determine our satisfaction with their service. I recommend them without hesitation.

Daniel McGiboney

Sep 28, 2021 Report

First of all do not leave your car here overnight under any circumstances, they will steal it. Manager claimed the keys were stuck in the car the night before, they got there in the morning and their gate was open and the car was gone, now who else thinks that sounds fishy? very shady overpriced dealings going on at this place, would not trust them to change my oil.