Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Tiltons Automotive Service If you're looking for a Worthington Auto Repair shop you can trust, consider Tiltons Automotive Service. Tiltons Automotive Service is Worthington's premier service and auto repair shop. Founded in 1989, we have been providing our friends, family, and neighbors in Central Ohio with dependable, trustworthy Auto Repair Services. Whether you need a major or minor repair, our skilled and ASE Master certified technicians can quickly diagnose and pinpoint solutions, saving you valuable time and money in the long term.
Follow us
Services
Andy Tilton first opened his shop in 1989. A car lover since before he can remember and as a hands on technician, Andy has worked in the automotive industry for over 40 years. Andy had worked in a small auto mechanic repair shop for 12 years before opening Tiltons Automotive Service. His goal was to change the image of the Auto Repair Industry.
Our auto repair shop is conveniently located in Columbus, OH. Our quality ASE (Automotive Service Excellence) certified mechanics at Tiltons Automotive Service employ today's latest automotive technology and are equipped to handle all major and minor auto repair services on foreign and domestic vehicles.
There's no greater peace of mind than knowing you have one less worry by having your vehicles serviced by the professionals at Tiltons Automotive Service. We stand behind our work with the Tiltons Automotive Service Nationwide Warranty. So no matter where your travels take you, if you ever experience a problem with a covered repair, you can count on Tiltons Automotive Service to assist you while out of town.
Is it really necessary to replace my timing belt at the manufacturer recommended interval? The failure of a timing belt in many cars can result in major engine damage. The cost of repairing an engine with a broken timing belt is much greater than the cost of a timing belt replacement. There are many sensors and computerized components that manage your vehicle's engine performance and emissions.
Reviews (23)
Write a Review
Sandra Fiore
Jun 17, 2022
This is the only place I will take my car for whatever it needs. I have been doing business with them for a number of years. They r the best. Services: Oil change, Tires
Stephen T. Reither
Jun 09, 2022
Van went in for head gasket. Said heads were to warped. Being that I have a auto reconditioning shop my self. I have good connections to get a replacement engine and trans. Which I had already explored that option. I'm to old to do this kind of work myself. They immediately added a so called handling charge of $750. They added fees wherever they could.

No integrity at all. Just plain greed! Ended up getting the van out. Paid them $900. Charge for tearing the engine down. Now I've still got to find someone to install engine and trans. There was no interest in adjusting there bill. I was looking at spending over $5500 with them plus what I spent for the engine and trans. There building a new facility across the road and there doing on the back of their customers. I don't know how they sleep at night. I've had a shop for 30 years. Never screwed customers. I only hope it catches up with them some day and becomes their downfall
Rob Zedeker
Jun 08, 2022
The Tiltons team has helped us out quite a few times. Always honest, trustworthy and straight up, quick to respond and they know their stuff. They're our sole car repair folks! Services: Auto maintenance, Engine repair, Brakes, Oil change, General repairs & maintenance, Tires, Wheel alignment, Vehicle safety inspection
Brad Hyatt
Jun 06, 2022
These folks are great -- they really care about their customers! I have had a particularly difficult transmission problem, and they have stuck with the problem until it was resolved. They also helped me with the warranty and dealing with the auto maker, etc. Plus, they are very friendly and easy to work with. I highly recommend them!
Javon Booth
Apr 03, 2022
I called to try and get my car looked at and the man who answer lied and said there was a charge for $100-130 just to look at my car and it would take an hour but there website literally says they have free inspections! This company is a rip off!
Scott F.
Feb 23, 2022
Everyone needs a mechanic you can trust, and I am thrilled to name Tiltson's as my trustworthy mechanic. Sprinkle in active local ownership that are part of the community, and you have a winning combination. We have been going here for years, and the only thing bad I can say is parking is a challenge.
Mike & Alyssa Hough
Jan 25, 2022
Great service. Car broke down on New Year's Eve and they fixed it the very next business day. Great customer support and the Vice President even followed up a week later to see if everything was still working great. Service: Engine repair
Miriel R.
Nov 17, 2021
We have used Tilton's since we moved to Worthington two years ago on the recommendation of locals. After our most recent experience, we will be loyal for life. I took my Honda Odyssey into Tilton's for what I thought was a minor fluid leak, but turned out to be a major engine problem. I cannot imagine an auto service provider being more honest, forthright, or helpful in such a situation.

After the technician diagnosed the problem, Andy and the Tilton's staff spent hours of their day facilitating a transfer to the dealership so that we could take advantage of our extended warranty. A dishonest auto service could have easily preyed on my relative ignorance and made a bunch of money out of the deal. Tilton's, on the other hand, went above and beyond to ensure we maximized our warranty benefits, and even towed the car to the dealership for us (for a fee, but it was far less hassle than getting a third party involved).

This major car problem came at a particularly stressful time, and it could have brought my family's life to a grinding halt. The integrity, character, and kindness that Andy, BC, and the whole Tilton's crew demonstrated was so far above and beyond their obligation that you can't even see the bare minimum from here. They saved us thousands of dollars (at their own expense, because it was the right thing to do), and they brought a degree of peace and ease into a process that was objectively quite stressful. We will be Tilton's customers for as long as we live here, and you should be too.
Sha'Ron White
May 15, 2021
I dropped my car off to be serviced for a water leak on the passenger side. I made it clear that I only wanted that side fixed and that it was possible the seal needing replaced. After having my car all day they told me the seal around my entire car was fine they saw nothing wrong. They send me a quote to replace the weather strips around the ENTIRE truck. Also, he mentioned that this may not fix my issue.

So tell me why would I trial and error and I sent my car there for you to know? I then asked how much it was to fix the seal for the passenger door only like I originally asked and he said he will get back to me the next day, Friday. I asked them some days later for a quote and they said they will not work on my car unless it's to replace the seals around my entire car and not just the door. Sounds money hungry. Why am I paying someone to fix something that is not the problem. Waste of my time. The dealer ended up being cheaper.
Liz L.
Apr 22, 2021
It was my first time visiting this location and every one was very friendly. They fixed my brakes and rotated my tires for free. That was very kind and thoughtful. The prices were a little more expensive but their service was outstanding. I highly recommend their business.
Michaela Kramer
Mar 09, 2021
Tiltons is awesome! As an OSU student not from Columbus, I was unsure if I would find a quality place that treated me well and didn't rip me off. Everyone at Tiltons was extremely friendly, understanding and super kind! They are amazing and I recommend them to everyone- super clean waiting room with complimentary WIFI/coffee/water as well. (review Spring 2017) Updated, August 2020: I found a sheet metal screw in my tire today at work which caused a flat tire (ironically I had just got all new tires 2 weeks ago-frustrating!) I called Tilton's and they sent a service truck to check it out.

They refilled the tire with air and I drove it to their Worthington shop a mile down the road. They immediately took my car back, removed the screw and patched the tire while I was able to sit in their nice waiting room and work remotely. From my initial phone call to me leaving their location, it was 40 minutes. Not to mention they patched my tire free of charge!

They have the friendliest staff, a clean facility and nice waiting room, and do quick, reliable work. This is my second great experience at Tilton's and I highly recommend them! Don't hesitate to call and have work done on your vehicle here!
David T.
Jan 11, 2021
Thankful to have found them! They worked on my AC and fan motor/dampers to get my vehicle cooled down this past summer.
St Moritz
Nov 20, 2020
My first experience with Tiltons was on New Year's Eve and one of my road supervisors had a tire that started leaking air he arrived at the shop five minutes before closing time and they still took the car in and patched the tire. With that level of professionalism they earned my business going forward. We have had a few more repairs sense in the quality and professionalism has never been less than stellar. Ray Davidson St. Moritz Security Branch Manager
James Humphres
Oct 19, 2020
Andy & the guys are great. There is no automotive problem they can’t fix. I only take my Camaro to them if it needs something. Great prices, Great people & Great service
Doug C.
Jan 16, 2020
We moved to the Columbus area 7 years ago, found Tilton's shortly after that...have not been disappointed. I usually do my own repairs but when I need help I turn to Andy and his crew. They are top notch and worth the money. Moreover they won't take advantage of those who know little about cars.....they will treat you right.
Dennis R.
Jul 12, 2019
Tiltons performed some major suspension work on my Saab convertible. Basically returning it to near 'factory new condition'. Following their initial diagnostic work all of the updates were completed in a timely fashion. In addition Tiltons kept me apprised of the repairs as the project proceeded with both phone calls and text messages. In fact they also did two follow-up inquiries to check up on their repairs.

Way to go! All in all I felt as if I was their most valued customer. Bottom line? Superb service all the way around. Five stars. Excellent service. Great job. Highly recommended. I am running out of superlatives to describe Tiltons. Thanks Tiltons for a great job.
Jay Shapiro
Feb 17, 2019
Tilton's Auto Service: expert, honest, dependable, caring, trustworthy, considerate, fairest pricing around. Need I say more? I am fortunate to have found Tilton's a few months after I moved to Columbus in November 2018 and wouldn't take my beloved older Hyundai Elantra any place else!
Peter K.
Jan 15, 2019
Honesty and Integrity are their specialties. My mother in law's car (Corolla) had been sitting idle in a garage for about a year. There was some evidence that mice had been in the trunk at least. At first, we took it to the dealer to evaluate for damage. We made the mistake of telling them about the mice and they tried to take advantage of us.

The dealer told us that mice had essentially crippled all the engine wiring and damages would cost 5-10k. Or, they would be willing to buy the car off of us (at a fraction of its worth!) to sell at auction. Turns out, the car was fine. There was only a very minor wire covering damage from the mice, which Tiltons patched for us at no charge. We needed new tires and an air filter, but the car had not been mortally wounded.

The dealer had LIED to us! What the dealer had told us would cost thousands to repair only cost us in the hundreds. I cannot tell you how much I appreciate the honest, professional service from Tiltons. We are going here from now on for all our automotive needs!
Helen L Baham
Jan 10, 2018
I am very grateful to Andy and the rest of his staff for helping me on every level possible. My car repairs were a big burden on me but without the help and concern of Tiltons and the excellent work The burden would have been impossible to bare. Thank you guys so much.
Meg D.
Aug 11, 2017
Just moved to the area, & needed a efficient trustworthy mechanic to keep my older car running as long as she possibly can. I got that and so much more with Tilton's. Incredible customer service. I brought my car in on Wednesday and they had it ready for me the next afternoon, they even gave me a free loaner car to drive overnight! Their facility is clean and equipped with any amenities you would need if you waited for your car there.

I have always dreaded needing to get my car fixed, at Tillton's they do everything possible to make that experience pleasant and hasslefree. Friendly payment options are available as well. My car has not run this smoothly in a very long time.
Jessie A.
Mar 14, 2017
This is probably the 5th time I have needed tilton's. Every single time they give amazing customer service. Honest mechanic shop that cares about their community as well! Will definetely continue to give our business to them, they are all awesome guys!
Thomas L.
Oct 19, 2016
Every family needs a doctor, lawyer, and a good trustworthy mechanic. Tilton should be that family mechanic. I had a simple problem with my tire, I called, I went, and in just 15 minutes, problem fixed. In addition, no charge! They asked that I just pay it forward or a donation to the Food Bank. I love family businesses. We need to support our local economy. And when you find one that is this friendly and efficient, it should be our only go to resource. Highly recommend for anything related to cars.
Amy B.
Oct 04, 2016
They are very friendly. They can usually squeeze you in. They support the community (local schools and sports teams). BUT, if they tell you that your car needs thousands of dollars in repairs, GET A SECOND OPINION!