Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Plains Tire At Plains Tire we guarantee the lowest prices on tires. With nine locations throughout Wyoming, you're sure to get the best deal nearest you. If you find a lower price on the same tire anywhere within six months of your purchase, we will pay the difference. We are committed to proving that Plains Tire in Wyoming has the lowest prices, period! We carry the major brand tires you know and trust at discount prices. Among our selection is Michelin, BFGoodrich, Uniroyal, Goodyear, Toyo, Continental and many more.
Follow us
Services
A properly maintained air conditioning system can help keep you comfortable on hot summer days. Did you know that a properly functioning A/C system is also instrumental in helping to defrost your windshield on those cold, damp winter days as well? A properly functioning A/C system helps to dehumidify the air passing through the defrosting system enabling your windows to quickly clear and stay fog free.
Reviews (18)
Write a Review
MaKayla Kallas
May 21, 2022
I had a wonderful experience Robert and Wayne went above and beyond for me and their technicians are awesome as well! I would definitely recommend them and will be going back In the future!
Barrett Lee
May 14, 2022
Volunteering to go pickup an illegal tire dump, not often you see that kind of integrity in the auto service industry. 5 stars in my books.
Joseph John
Apr 14, 2022
We had an accident just west of Evanston on I-80 where our passenger side tires and wheels were destroyed. Our Jeep was towed to Les Schwab Plains Tire Center at the recommendation of the tow truck driver. We started working with Robert who diagnosed the need for both tires and new wheels and provided aftermarket solutions. Although we opted for matching wheels and tires thru the local Jeep dealership, the diagnosis and detailed recommendations provided by Robert were so very helpful.

After all their work, Robert refused to charge me a dime - in this day and age, it was so refreshing. Although I didn't actually have them do the work, the business approach is absolutely worth a 5 star rating. If I'm ever in need of their services and I find myself in Evanston, they will get my business.
Sherri Rose
Feb 15, 2022
Unfortunately my tire fell off my car in IL on my way home in Michigan! So I wouldn't go back or recommend anyone go there or think of going there. The claims department has been very helping and understanding, would definitely like to say Thank you to CLAIMS
Roseanne Johnson
Feb 09, 2022
Excellent Service! The staff is always courteous and very efficient. They are always willing to work on any problem we have and always work us in if possible. They have helped with seemingly impossible situations.
Nikka Cap
Jan 09, 2022
Drove through Wyoming on our way to California and we noticed our tire was losing pressure/air We were able to go to Plains Tire and they fixed it within 30 mins ($22)! Thank you for the speedy service.
Andy R.
Oct 26, 2021
Great tire shop! Called first thing in the morning to check availability for tire rotation for an F250 and 26' travel trailer, LOF and replace seals and repack the bearings on the RV. "Bring it right over!" We got there at 8:30 am and were out around 10:00 am! Be aware they get busy fast and it's first come first serve! The boys did a great job!
Aric Metz
Oct 22, 2021
This is the best tire store I have ever been to. They noticed that another tire company had put the wrong tires on my one ton van and notified me they were the wrong size and not listed for the weight of my vehicle. With their help we replaced all four tires with the best tires on the market and I am pleased to say they work great and I feel safe now using my van for work and travel. Thank you Plains Tire.
Evit D.
May 14, 2021
The worst experience ever the man who changed my tires stalled my car, left the the plastic seat cover and floor mat in my car and stretched my parking break. I recommend going somewhere else! I worked at a tire shop and this one place I would stay away from!
David Pasenelli
Apr 10, 2021
Superior products and services. The staff are awesome. Honest and friendly and give great deals. The only ones I buy tires from. If they don't have what u want they will order it and install it asap with integrity. Thank you for handling my tire needs Plains Tires.
Chris Birli
Apr 09, 2021
I had a real head-scratching problem with a squeak that was so difficult to find. Three other shops from Denver to Salt Lake couldn't fix it, including TWO Land Rover dealers, and these guys figured it out. Quality, smart and kind fellas at Plain Tire. Thank again boys for getting me back on my expedition!
Loretta D.
Mar 12, 2021
I highly recommend these guys for tires! We went in for a set of four. They gave us three options and the prices were great! Plus they found a problem with a tie rod.replaced it and the tires in the same day! Awesome customer service and communication of recommended services needed. Will spread the word and return! Thanks guys!
David Schieno
Nov 17, 2020
Jason and crew were absolutely amazing! They had multiple people volunteer to stay late on Saturday night to get me back on the road. Absolutely thrilled about their service, attitude, prices, and service. I had to get towed 70 miles (30 miles passed other tire shops that aren't open on the weekend. I am from out of state and after getting my second flat tire in 24 hours and arranging for the long tow I was not in the best mood. Again, these guys stayed an hour late on a Saturday, was cheaper than they quoted me (including their protection plan!).

They truly helped me out of a pickle and had me out of there before the tow truck driver was done with the paperwork. Seriously, 4 tires after hours and done in 10-15 min! Thanks Jason and everyone! I'll be singing praises for a very long time!
Lillian B.
May 07, 2019
Great place. They have great service and always provide options and the truth. They don't try to rip you off. If you're a little car dumb like me, this is the place for you. They can explain everything and help you with every detail. They're great on communication as well. I've been in here twice and both times they were able to fix the problem within an hour.
Nick A.
Sep 24, 2016
I was mislead and lied to when I purchased new tires. I called ahead (I live 3 hours drive from their location in Casper) and asked if Plains tire would price match Costco and match a $50 promotion Costco/BFG was offering. They did match the price of the tire and told me they matched the promotion. When I checked out I noticed there was only a $20 discount not $50. When confronted on this I was lied to and told they did match the promotion, then told that Plains tire would not match any other competitor's promotions.
Bob L.
Mar 18, 2015
I have been using these guys for my maintenance and repairs and have had very good experiences. Pricing has been reasonable as well. The biggest plus for me is that they have always been able to fit me in, no matter how busy they are. There is also a convenient waiting spot. They are pretty friendly but get right to business. I'm glad they are focused on getting the job done.

They just seem to crank it all right out. I have still kept two stars off because their tires really are overpriced. The generic, no name brand ones especially. If it weren't so expensive, I might have bought my tires there, but alas it's not the case. I would recommend them for service but not for buying tires.
Brooke S.
Jul 09, 2014
As someone who just moved to Laramie, it's sometimes hard to trust a new car shop and I am very happy with my service here so far. The guys working seem like experts and have helped me greatly with routine maintenance and one problem in my car. With the problem they showed, and explained, to me exactly what was wrong which I appreciated and fully trusted their advice.
Tonia D.
May 18, 2014
While heading back from Cheyenne earlier in the week, we suffered a blowout near Buford. After limping back to Laramie on the spare, I started making plans for getting it replaced. Although I had received a recommendation to go elsewhere, that station wasn't open on a Saturday. PTB, however, is open all day on Saturday. Yay! I rolled up around 2 in the afternoon, and was met with a rather pleasant gentleman who was more than happy to take a look and try to match my tires.

He didn't try to upsell. He didn't treat me like a lost little girl. He simply took care of my request, and I was out of there in less than an hour. Not only did he match my tire, but the price was right in line with what I paid when I bought them (slightly cheaper, actually) in Georgia a few years ago. I will most definitely be back next month to replace the tire on the other side to maintain even wear.