Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
First Choice Motors 1st Choice Motors., has the experience to handle nearly any kind of repair that you require. We are always pleased to consider your specific automotive service requirements. We know that you have a choice of auto repair shops in the area and we evaluate your consideration. Our hope is that you will feel confident in our capability to suit all of your expectations.
Follow us
Reviews (13)
Write a Review
Fast Forward AvidGamer
May 26, 2022
I don't often get our vehicles towed, but I was lucky to find out about Milelli's Auto Service by sheer luck (through Google Search). After some comparative shopping, Milelli's was found to have the most reasonable pricing. Nick, the driver who picked up our car came, came as scheduled, got our car to the dealership within the timeframe they stated, and even provided us with feedback from the dealership with our car's issues. I felt that they truly did an excellent job in handling our situation and would have no qualms with using them again! Thank you.
Derek Tomasino
Mar 15, 2022
Have been coming here for a few years now and will continue to come here for a very long time. Steve and the crew there are very honest, helpful and go out of their way to take care of their customers. Can't say enough good things about them. Only place I would take my cars.
Steven K.
Mar 05, 2022
A bit off Morristown's beaten path. New customer who just moved to the area. Couldn't be happier: Steve + Nick x2 were all super professional, approachable, quick and most important: Honest. Saturday hours are an extra plus.
Michael Pierre
Mar 15, 2021
Very helpful people. they discovered my car had a recall issue, which joyce honda never told me about and joyce honda was going to charge me 339.90. Thanks to Milelli, I didn't pay a single cent for that repair. I highly recommend Milelli. Services: A/c installation & repair, Transmission
Fred Passarella
Jan 25, 2021
I was looking for another auto service center after having had enough of dealerships and the national chains and I decided to give Milelli's a try. I met Steve, the owner, and was he was very polite, friendly and professional. He explained everything, answered my questions and made me feel very comfortable with the prices and options for parts. Work was completed quickly and I was extremely happy with the quality of the work and the price! They also have a towing service, which is good to have in an emergency. I highly recommend Milelli's and will be using them again!
Nadine Bibi
Oct 26, 2020
Called about a jump start as the place I usually go didn't have the ability to come to you. Steve was professional & friendly on the phone, and his son Nick came to the rescue soon after. He got the car running again, and was very pleasant & nice. No complaints!
Linda Mazzaro
Jul 28, 2020
I was taking my mom for surgery at Morristown hospital when as we pull into the parking garage my brakes fail. I live over an hour away. I googled Auto Repair near me and Milelli's Auto was an option. Since they had 4.5 stars I chose them. Well I would give them10 stars if I could! Steve went out of his way to help and try to get my vehicle done before he closed so I can drive home and not take an Uber which would cost $50. If you are in the vicinity of Morristown and have trouble with your vehicle I would recommend Milelli's in a heartbeat!
Dewain Crim Jr
Jun 20, 2020
I have been a customer here for over 15 years. Not once have I been disappointed. Not one time. Straightforward estimates, repair time estimates, and on the off chance your car will be taking longer, you will get a phone call well ahead so you can plan. If you do not need it fixed, Steve will tell you. No added on service that is not necessary, like the highway dealers. This business makes its money based on one principle: Do it right, the first time. You will be happy, you will tell your friends.
Shelby Estra
Jun 16, 2020
I go here for all of my auto needs (Mercedes and Chevy). Started out needing a tow to the dealership and when the dealership quoted over $700, Milelli's offered to pick up my car again only bring it to their shop for a much more reasonable service fee. I have been using them ever since and recommend to anyone.
Alexander Tholl
Jan 21, 2020
My family and I were with Tom of First Choice Motors for over 20 Years and during his retirement transition he merged businesses with Milellis Auto. Naturally we were inclined to move with him and we are glad we did, to no surprise, Steve and his team have the same values and ethics as Tom did at First Choice. The service is the best because his team has excellent experience and care about the work they perform, unlike the dealerships who just have (unqualified) bodies. Steve has a team which care about properly diagnosing the problems and correctly fixing them, not just throwing parts at your car and hoping for the best.

If there is an issue, he takes care of it period. His prices may be a bit higher than others in town but there is a reason he has loyal repeat customers and an influx of new ones. The saying holds true you get what you pay for. Treat them with respect and you'll get 10 fold. If this wasn't enough, I highly recommend Milellis.
Siddharth Suri
Jan 06, 2020
I have nothing but highly positive interactions with Milelli's. Steve and Victor are top-notch, focused on their customers and most importantly, honest. The mechanics are good, and Steve's son Nick is following in the footsteps here as well. I've had multiple interactions with them where they recommended low-cost repairs (or no work) when someone else would charge up as much as possible.

They take care three cars in my household (one of which seems to be always in trouble). They always make time and take care of our issues right away. I've also had emergency issues that they dropped everything to fix. I had an issue a few months ago when we had just started on a long road trip to a wedding. Had a flat, the spare was rusted in. We had to get towed to the shop.

I called Steve and asked for some urgent help. They took us in, cut out the spare, fixed the flat and gave us a spare tire in case we had an emergency. All within an hour. They are good people. I highly recommend them!
Ali Skylar
Dec 03, 2018
Steve and Tom are the best! We find their service fees, work, and customer service top notch. Steve has been so helpful and generous with his time these past couple of weeks as we search for a new car and work to sell an older car. I would recommend them highly!
Ray Lewis
Aug 13, 2017
I have now been to Milelli's on 3 separate occasions, and I can't say enough about the exceptional service I received each time. Here are a couple of quick anecdotes that shed some light on the kind of people they are: 1. On one occasion, I couldn't get my car to start so I called Milelli's to come tow it. They could've just showed up and towed it without even seeing what was wrong with the car, as that would've made them more money. Instead, they successfully attempted to start my car and allowed me to avoid the towing charge.

I can't imagine many businesses have that level of integrity. 2. Another time, I brought my car in on Saturday towards closing time. If I didn't get it back that day it wouldn't be ready until Monday and I wouldn't have been able to get to work. Steve had no obligation to do so, but he stayed late that day to make sure I got my car back in time. Not only that, but he never tries to squeeze extra charges into my bills.

In summary, I see a number of reviews describe Milelli's as "honest", "fast", and "reasonably priced", and I couldn't agree more. I'd highly recommend Milelli's to anyone who needs their car serviced in the Morristown area.